Peaches have been in season for the last couple of weeks. Schnucks had Eckerts peaches for sale so I bought some. There were really good, so I bought more.
Katie asked me for the recipe for peach freezer jam, which I think is about tied with strawberry for the best freezer jam ever. I responded to Katie that the best way to make freezer jam is to buy the pectin and use the recipe that comes in the package. Thinking about peach freezer jam got my taste buds really going, so I made peach freezer jam that evening. It was really good.
Then I decided that jam was not enough, so the next night, I made a peach pie. Since the best way to eat peach pie is with vanilla ice cream on top, I made a new batch of homemade vanilla ice cream using mom’s new ice cream maker.
We have used the peach pie recipe in the Betty Crocker cookbook for years, but I did a search on the internet for peach pie to see if I could find something even better. I found the following recipe: http://allrecipes.com/Recipe/Peach-Pie/Detail.aspx
After reading many of the reviews, I decided to compare it to the Betty Crocker recipe before deciding how I wanted to make the pie. The recipe from Allrecipes.com listed 10 peaches while Betty Crocker called for 5 cups of sliced peaches. My peaches were big and 5 peaches resulted in 5 cups. The recipe at Allrecipes.com called for 1/3 cup flour compared to Betty Crocker’s ¼ cup and Allrecipes.com called for twice as much butter and no cinnamon and no lemon juice. I used the flour and butter amounts from Allrecipe.com and used the lemon juice amount from Betty Crocker. I omitted the cinnamon.
The Betty Crocker recipe has you mix the lemon juice, sugar, cinnamon and flour into the peach slices and then put the butter on the peach mixture. The Allrecipes.com method mixes the sugar, flour and butter into a crumbly mixture. The peaches and crumb mixture are layered in the pie shell. I took a photo of the pie just before the top crust went on.
When I put the top crust on, I did not do a very good job of sealing the edge, so juice leaked out of the edges instead of the top when it cooked. I made my typical cinnamon and sugar sprinkled pie crust strips and put them into the oven when I baked the pie. I put them in a pan under the pie but on top of the cookie sheet on the second shelf that catches the juice. I forgot about the pie crust strips and remembered them when the pie was almost done. They were a bit overcooked, but much of the peach juice had dripped on the pie crust strips. They were quite good. I used the Betty Crocker cooking method of 425 degrees for 15 minutes with foil to prevent over browning and then reducing to 350 degrees. One of the comments on the peach pie recipe at Allrecipes.com said that one way to prevent the peach pie from being too runny was to leave it in the oven for a while after turning off the heat so the juices can continue to cook and set up without overcooking the crust. I did this. Also, this recipe has a little more flour than the Betty Crocker recipe which also makes it set up well. Once the pie was cooled, it was nice and firm.

The first piece was not firm, because it was still hot. Fresh homemade ice cream cooled it down nicely. It not only looks really good in the photo, it tasted really, really, really good.

I’m not sure if there will be any left when Joseph gets home Saturday night. I might just have to make another one.
Katie asked me for the recipe for peach freezer jam, which I think is about tied with strawberry for the best freezer jam ever. I responded to Katie that the best way to make freezer jam is to buy the pectin and use the recipe that comes in the package. Thinking about peach freezer jam got my taste buds really going, so I made peach freezer jam that evening. It was really good.
Then I decided that jam was not enough, so the next night, I made a peach pie. Since the best way to eat peach pie is with vanilla ice cream on top, I made a new batch of homemade vanilla ice cream using mom’s new ice cream maker.
We have used the peach pie recipe in the Betty Crocker cookbook for years, but I did a search on the internet for peach pie to see if I could find something even better. I found the following recipe: http://allrecipes.com/Recipe/Peach-Pie/Detail.aspx
After reading many of the reviews, I decided to compare it to the Betty Crocker recipe before deciding how I wanted to make the pie. The recipe from Allrecipes.com listed 10 peaches while Betty Crocker called for 5 cups of sliced peaches. My peaches were big and 5 peaches resulted in 5 cups. The recipe at Allrecipes.com called for 1/3 cup flour compared to Betty Crocker’s ¼ cup and Allrecipes.com called for twice as much butter and no cinnamon and no lemon juice. I used the flour and butter amounts from Allrecipe.com and used the lemon juice amount from Betty Crocker. I omitted the cinnamon.
The Betty Crocker recipe has you mix the lemon juice, sugar, cinnamon and flour into the peach slices and then put the butter on the peach mixture. The Allrecipes.com method mixes the sugar, flour and butter into a crumbly mixture. The peaches and crumb mixture are layered in the pie shell. I took a photo of the pie just before the top crust went on.
The first piece was not firm, because it was still hot. Fresh homemade ice cream cooled it down nicely. It not only looks really good in the photo, it tasted really, really, really good.
I’m not sure if there will be any left when Joseph gets home Saturday night. I might just have to make another one.
